Reporting Discrimination
GRIEVANCE POLICY
Approved by the University Executive Council on August 7, 2007
Amended by the Board of Trustees on September 6 & 7, 2007
Amended by the Board of Trustees on September 14 & 15, 2023
Policy Statement:
The Lebanese American University believes in providing its employees and students with a fair and efficient process to present, and resolve, grievances arising out of the non-compliance or breach of an approved University Policy or Procedure.
All University constituents are encouraged to seek and obtain answers to questions, or concerns, relating to their involvement with the University, through available procedures.
Regular and effective communications between the University constituents reduces the likelihood of misunderstanding and conflict. The University expects and encourages students, staff, and faculty members to communicate openly, and regularly, so that their interests, and the University’s interests, are best served.
Students, staff, and faculty members are entitled to utilize this Policy if the informal discussions did not result in disposing of the complaint to the satisfaction of the complainant, and provided the complained about matter involves a breach of a University Policy or Procedure.
Definition:
A Grievance is defined as an unresolved issue concerning a breach of a University Policy or Procedure that caused the grievant harm or damage.
This Policy does not apply to matters that are governed by alternative University review through applying other policies such as the Discrimination, Harassment and Sexual Misconduct Prevention Policy, the Personnel Policy - Faculty, the Fraud Policy, and the Code of Ethics etc …
This Policy applies whenever the grievance is not covered by any other existing University Policy.
Retaliation Prohibited:
The University, expressly, and unequivocally, prohibits retaliation against any person who files a grievance or assists a grievant in his/her efforts.
However, it is considered to be a serious misconduct if a grievance was filed and found to include deliberate false statements, and/or misleading and inaccurate facts. Such offense will be subject to the full range of disciplinary sanctions, including termination and dismissal for cause, and suspension.
Title IX at LAU
LAU has a no-tolerance policy for gender discrimination, sexual harassment and sexual assault. Title IX actively supports a campus environment where gender discrimination and sexual harassment are not tolerated. Committed to a working and learning environment where people can achieve their full potential, Title IX works to spread awareness about benefits of equity, diversity and inclusion for individuals and the entire community.
The Title IX Office at LAU provides information, confidential discussion, training/awareness materials, and networking regarding eliminating gender discrimination and sexual harassment or misconduct for the LAU community.
About Title IX - Equity and Inclusion at LAU
What is Title IX?
Title IX is a 1972 education amendment to the American Civil Rights law that prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in any federally funded education program or activity. The main goal of Title IX is to avoid the use of federal money to support sex discrimination in education programs and to provide individual citizens effective protection against those practices.
Title IX applies to all aspects of federally funded education programs or activities. In addition to traditional educational institutions such as colleges, universities, and elementary and secondary schools, Title IX also applies to any education or training program operated by a recipient of federal financial assistance. Title IX seeks to ensure that there is equal access to education regardless of gender. Over time, this has come to be understood as not only prohibiting discrimination, harassment and sexual assault at educational institutions but also working to address long-term structural inequalities and obstacles hindering education progress.
Who and What are included?
While Title IX has a particular focus on students, it also includes all individuals who work for educational institutions. All employees (staff, faculty, etc.) are protected by and responsible for implementing Title IX.
Title IX also applies to the physical space of the institution. All visitors to schools, college and university campuses must also adhere to Title IX. In other words, all gender discrimination and harassment are prohibited at educational institutions that receive US Federal Government funding.
Why does LAU adhere to Title IX?
LAU is both a Lebanese and an American university. It is registered by both governments and seeks to comply with all applicable laws. LAU also receives research funding, scholarships and other grants from the US Federal Government.
Beyond compliance, LAU’s mission and values highlight the importance to “respect human dignity, promote gender equality, and be inclusive” and LAU is rooted in the core liberal arts beliefs that all individuals who seek to study and work to the best of their abilities should have the opportunity to do so. In addition, individuals are unique with unique capabilities and interests—this diversity makes LAU richer and better able to live up to its vision. Committing to implementing Title IX helps LAU to:
- Provide access to a superior education for diverse undergraduate and graduate students and lifelong learners;
- Attract and retain distinguished faculty who excel in teaching, research and community service;
- Enroll and retain academically qualified and diverse students;
- Embrace liberal arts in all curricula;
- Create opportunities for rigorous research and the dissemination of knowledge;
- Develop a close-knit community that excels academically, is intellectually stimulating, and is religiously, ethnically and socio-economically diverse;
- Attract and retain a highly qualified staff committed to excellence in service.
LAU’s Title IX Office focuses on five components to comply with Title IX regulations:
Compliance: It seeks to ensure LAU is compliant with Title IX policies and procedures of the Department of Education and US Federal Law.
Policy Recommendations: The Title IX Office reviews and makes recommendations for revision of LAU policies and procedures to better meet the requirements of Title IX—eliminating discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct.
Advocacy and Support for Equity & Inclusion: the Office seeks to provide advocacy and support for greater equity and inclusion at LAU through participating in university committees, meeting with and participating in club activities, and keeping an active communications campaign on campus, among other means.
Training: The Title IX Office is responsible for providing on-going training for students, staff, and faculty regarding rights and responsibilities of gender equity and inclusion and the prohibition of discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct.
Complaints Management: The Office is the main office receiving and participating in investigations of complaints of gender discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct.
Discrimination, Harassment and Sexual Misconduct Prevention Policy
The Lebanese American University and all its affiliates (collectively “LAU”) is committed to pursuing excellence in its academic and professional endeavors, as well as believing in the intrinsic value of all individuals. LAU fosters an atmosphere of mutual respect among all members of its community, where each individual is judged solely on criteria related to academic or job performance. LAU is committed to the elimination of all forms of discrimination, harassment and sexual misconduct on its campuses or on any other University controlled area or event.
Fundamental to LAU’s mission is the preservation and encouragement of academic freedom. Promulgating this Policy should by no means be construed as inhibiting free speech, freedom of association, or the free communication of ideas.
POLICY STATEMENT
LAU has a zero tolerance rule for acts of discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct. LAU is an equal opportunity employer and does not permit discrimination due to race, color, religion, creed, gender, marital status, national origin, disability, age, sexual orientation, political affiliation, pregnancy, or belief. LAU is committed to a working and learning environment where people can achieve their full potential.
This Policy:
- Supports an environment where it is clear that discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct are unacceptable, thereby reducing the chance that discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct will occur in the first instance;
- Applies to all LAU staff, faculty, and students in connection with their roles, duties, and responsibilities at LAU whether as an employee or a member of the student body;
- Ensures that all visitors, including but not limited to individuals such as suppliers, service providers and guest speakers are held to LAU’s highest standards of behavior and will be held responsible for any act of discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct against a member or members of the LAU community;
- Provides procedures to notify LAU of potential discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct so that LAU may take appropriate action to investigate and address any such prohibited actions; and
- Prohibits retaliation against persons notifying LAU of such prohibited actions.
- Disciplinary action may be taken to deal with actions or behavior, intentional or unintentional, which results in a violation of this policy. In general, the procedures for review of complaints and discipline for a violation of this policy are addressed in this policy and other LAU policies relating to employee and student conduct. LAU may publish additional procedures in compliance with relevant laws and regulations.
CONDUCT SUBJECT TO THIS POLICY
DISCRIMINATION
Discrimination is treatment of a person less favorably than other persons based on age, race, color, religion, creed, gender (including pregnancy), sexual orientation, marital status, nationality, disability, political affiliation or any other basis protected by applicable law.
HARASSMENT
Harassment is the making of any unwelcome advances or requests for favors or other conduct when (i) submission to such conduct is made either explicitly or implicitly a term or condition of an individual’s employment, a student’s performance, or participation in any campus activity; (ii) submission to or rejection of such conduct by an individual is used as the basis for decisions related to employment, academic performance, or student activities; or (iii) such conduct has the purpose or effect of substantially or unreasonably interfering with an individual’s work, academic performance, or participation in student life by creating an intimidating, hostile, or offensive work or campus environment. Harassment may take physical, verbal, visual, or online forms.
Harassment also includes behavior that demeans, humiliates, or embarrasses a person based on race, national or ethnic origin, color, religion, age, gender, marital status, family status, disability, or sexual orientation, and that a reasonable person should have known would be unwelcome. It includes actions such as touching and pushing, comments such as jokes and name-calling, displays such as posters and cartoons and disrespectful behavior commonly known as ‘personal’ harassment, such as making fun of personal circumstances or appearance, bullying (includes unmerited criticism, isolation, gossip, physical violence or violent gestures, public humiliation, or behavior that is intimidating or demeaning), and stalking.
SEXUAL MISCONDUCT
Sexual misconduct is any form of Sexual Assault connected with forced sexual contact, including but not limited to rape. Force can be physical or emotional (there are four types of force: physical, threat, intimidation, coercion). Sexual Assault consists of Sexual Contact and/or Sexual Intercourse that occurs without Affirmative Consent. Sexual Contact is any intentional sexual touching, however slight with any object or body part performed by a person upon another person. Sexual Intercourse is any penetration, however slight with any object or body part performed by a person upon another person and is considered Rape if the action is taken without the affirmative consent of the other individual(s).
Affirmative Consent must be informed (knowing), voluntary (freely given), and active (not passive), meaning that, through the demonstration of clear words or actions, a person has indicated permission to engage in mutually agreed-upon sexual activity (contact or intercourse). Affirmative Consent cannot be gained by taking advantage of the incapacitation of another individual, where the person initiating sexual activity knew or reasonably should have known that the other was incapacitated. Incapacitation means that a person lacks the ability to make informed, rational judgments about whether or not to engage in sexual activity.
Affirmative Consent cannot be obtained by force. Force includes (a) the use of physical violence, (b) threats, (c) intimidation, and/or (d) coercion. Physical violence means that a person is exerting control over another person through the use of physical force. Examples of physical violence include hitting, punching, slapping, kicking, restraining, choking, and brandishing or using any weapon. Threats are words or actions that would compel a reasonable person to engage in unwanted activity. Examples include threats to harm a person physically, to reveal private information to harm a person’s reputation, or to cause a person academic or economic harm. Intimidation is an implied threat that menaces or causes reasonable fear in another individual, including the stalking of another individual. Coercion is the use of an unreasonable amount of pressure to gain access to something or someone. Coercion is more than an effort to convince, lure, or attract another person to have sex. When an individual is clear that they do not want to participate in a particular form of Sexual Contact or Sexual Intercourse, that they want to stop, or that they do not want to go beyond a certain sexual interaction, continued pressure can be coercive. Factors that may indicate coercion include the frequency, intensity and duration of the application of the pressure and the degree of isolation of the person being pressured.
RETALIATION
LAU prohibits retaliation against any individual because he or she in good faith reports alleged incidents of discrimination, harassment or sexual misconduct, pursues a discrimination, harassment or sexual misconduct claim, or cooperates or participates in an investigation of such reports. Discipline, reprisal, intimidation, or other forms of retaliation in such situations is a serious violation of this policy and may result in disciplinary action, up to and including termination of employment or expulsion from the university.
RESPONSIBILITIES
All staff, faculty and students:
- Must attend education programs provided by LAU relating to discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct.
- Can prevent discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct by being sensitive to the reactions and needs of others, and ensuring that their conduct does not cause offence;
- Can discourage discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct by others through making it clear that such conduct is unacceptable.
- LAU is responsible for:
- Providing an environment where it is clear that discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct are not acceptable;
- Taking action when it has clear notice that discrimination, harassment, or sexual misconduct has taken or is taking place to stop the conduct, prevent its recurrence, and remedy its effects.
- Ensuring that deans and chairpersons, vice presidents, and directors are aware of their responsibilities under this policy, including trying to prevent or to report violations of this policy.
REPORTING ACTS OF DISCRIMINATION, HARASSMENT OR SEXUAL MISCONDUCT
Any LAU staff, faculty or student who believes in good faith that he/she or someone else at LAU has been a victim of discrimination, harassment or any form of sexual misconduct should promptly notify LAU through one of the methods set out below. Notices should provide information as to the conduct, where it occurred and persons involved and, if reporting is not by the victim should explain how the person reporting has knowledge of the conduct. LAU will review such notice, initiate an investigation and take any measures, adjudicatory or otherwise, it determines appropriate in response to the notice. Further, LAU may advise certain staff and faculty with oversight of student well-being that their duties include a requirement to report instances of sexual misconduct relating to students promptly upon receiving such information.
The right to confidentiality shall be strictly adhered to at all stages, in so far as it does not interfere with LAU’s legal obligation to investigate the allegations presented and to take the proper corrective action.
A failure to provide prompt notification or the reporting of information anonymously may hinder LAU’s ability to act on the conduct for which a complaint is made.
PROCEDURES AND RESOLUTION OF COMPLAINTS
The following steps should be taken when filing a complaint:
When a student, a staff member, or a faculty member faces any form of harassment, s/he should notify (orally or in writing) the Title IX Office at TitleIX@lau.edu.lb or by phone at 01.786.456, ext. 1303.
Anonymous Reporting: Anyone can make an anonymous report of conduct prohibited under this Policy by contacting the Compliance Hotline at 01.786.456 ext. 4444.
In case of a health or safety emergency, students, staff and faculty should contact 01.786.456 ext.1500 on the Beirut campus or 09.547.262 ext. 2500 on the Byblos campus to address the emergency and reports under this policy should be made later.
When a complaint is submitted, LAU may request a statement in writing signed by the complainant in order to proceed with further inquiry, particularly in matters relating to employment.
Depending on the type of conduct and the persons affected, the complaint may be referred to an existing LAU procedure for resolution such as the Grievance Policy or the Student Code of Conduct. Further, LAU may establish new procedures as necessary and, if needed, to comply with the U.S. Department of Education requirements, in order to investigate the claim.
LAU will promptly investigate all complaints. Thereafter, upon the President’s request, the Title IX Coordinator, will manage all complaints that warrant investigation. The President can consider engaging other university units as necessary and in keeping with this Policy. If the Title IX Coordinator determines that the complaint is credible, he/she shall notify the Office of the General Counsel and will work closely with it during the consideration and investigation of the complaint. Furthermore, the Office of the General Counsel provides advice and direction on the legal aspects of Title IX-related investigations and potential prosecutions. The Office of the General Counsel will conduct Title IX investigations involving an employee or employees of the Title IX Office.
If LAU determines that the claim is substantiated, LAU will institute disciplinary proceedings against the offending party, which may result in a range of sanctions up to and including termination of University employment or expulsion.
If LAU determines that the complaint was unsubstantiated, the University will take no corrective action.
The formal University decision shall be communicated to all involved parties as approved by the President. Appeals by either party may be initiated as per the applicable LAU policies.
TRAINING AND EDUCATION
Leadership, education, training, awareness, and intervention are essential in preventing and eliminating acts of discrimination, harassment, and sexual misconduct. It is the responsibility of every member of the LAU community to attend the training and awareness sessions required by LAU.
Effective Date
The foregoing Discrimination, Harassment and Sexual Misconduct Prevention Policy of the Lebanese American University was amended by the Board of Trustees on September 6, 2019 and is effective as of September 6, 2019. This Policy was originally effective as of June 7, 2003, and was previously amended on March 9 & 10, 2006; March 15 & 16, 2013; and on September 7 & 8, 2017.
Work-Life Balance: Are You Doing It Right?
Faculty from the Psychology Program at the School of Arts and Sciences highlight the application of psychology in the professional world, its benefits and ways to address common workplace challenges.
Since childhood, before we even get the chance to think for ourselves, we are asked what we want to be when we grow up. These aspirations may subconsciously become inseparable from our identity. Instead of wanting to work as something, we grow up believing that we must be our profession.
In the work environment, as the lines between professional and personal life often blur, navigating the demands of career and personal wellbeing is necessary to achieving harmony between work and life. But how easy can that balance be found in today’s fast-paced world?
This was the catalyst for debate in a workshop titled The Art Of Living: Strategies For Work-Life Harmony held on September 1 at the Gilbert and Rose-Marie Chagoury Health Sciences Center, LAU Byblos campus.
Assistant Professor of Clinical Psychology Pia Tohme and Assistant Professor of Psychology Myriam El Khoury-Malhame took center stage to clarify several misconceptions related to the professional realm, mostly those associated with the myth of maintaining an unbending and constant work-life equilibrium.
What are the challenges of maintaining a work-life balance?
There is no concrete or straightforward answer to this question, as multiple factors come into play. Based on a poll conducted during the workshop, faculty, staff and medical doctors indicated that understaffing, poor time management and a heavy workload, to name a few, make it difficult for individuals to achieve equilibrium between their professional and personal lives.
“We’ve glamorized business to make it seem as if it’s what defines us,” said Dr. El-Khoury Malhame. Being busy, nonetheless, leads us to develop multiple identities varying from breadwinners to caregivers, with each having to prioritize a host of things at once.
This situation was exacerbated by our dependence on online mediums during the COVID-19 era, which effectively erased the demarcation between our personal and office lives. Consequently, work-related expectations became such that we were expected to be available at all times.
“This also affects our relationships,” said Dr. Tohme, given that it raises questions related to “how well we are managing ourselves as people, as partners, as parents and also as employees.”
These factors create a real hurdle where individuals feel pushed not just to aim for a balance between work and home life, but also to consider dealing with each part separately when managing personal relationships. Instead of trying to find one-size-fits-all solutions to merge work and home life, employees may need to figure out how to adjust their priorities for each area in order to recharge and effectively manage their commitments and time.
How does this impact us as individuals?
Most days, we bring the weight of our professional responsibilities into our personal lives and vice versa, which disrupts this delicate equilibrium. Excessive demands in the workplace tend to foster a heightened sense of tension and unease in our personal lives, impacting the quality of our relationships at home.
This, in turn, can cultivate a sense of guilt for reacting excessively, which further obstructs our ability to find solace and tranquility in our homes. The audience gave the example of having to work on weekends or check emails after hours.
Given these intricate dynamics, it is not surprising that we find ourselves caught “in a vicious cycle,” as Dr. Tohme called it, where the demands at work encroach upon our personal lives, and the demands in our personal lives affect our work. This cycle, if left unchecked, can ultimately lead to burnout.
It’s easy to overlook the fact that we are the same individuals navigating both spheres in this narrative. When we compartmentalize work as the medium of reason and life as the domain of emotion, we set ourselves on a course where the efficacy of our work diminishes. Consequently, we compromise our ability to process information cohesively and holistically.
“To improve this work-life balance is to reintegrate both mediums,” noted Dr. El Khoury-Malhame.
What can be done to achieve a work-life balance?
“There’s no magical solution,” stated the assistant professors. According to them, an employee often gets lost in trying to achieve this balance, but it’s not a one-person job. The effort has to come from both ends of the spectrum: the employer and the employee.
A few strategies for doing so, as suggested by Dr. Tohme and Dr. El Khoury-Malhame, revolve around perceiving the faculty and staff as individuals rather than commodities, promoting and setting boundaries and increasing self-reflection at work. According to the audience, this is done by fostering a supportive working environment in which conversations around mental health and consideration of basic needs are appraised, such as investing in healthcare, transportation, flexible/hybrid schedules, training, childcare areas, and showing appreciation, among others.
Assessing how one processes information is also essential among colleagues. Employers model their boundaries to their employees; thus, seeing how the latter is receiving certain types of tasks and instructions helps them implement such boundaries constructively.
“Our predictors of happiness mostly fall within the relationships we have with others,” said Dr. Tohme and Dr. El Khoury-Malhame. “Being aware of our boundaries and reflecting upon them allows us to control, influence and accept our dynamics with each other.”
At the end of the workshop, focus was placed on self-reflection, and taking the time to consider how one’s personal attitudes, actions and emotional reactions might help identify one’s difficulties and capacities as well as influence individuals’ experiences in their professional lives. By reflecting on and understanding their behaviors and reactions, both employees and employers can better navigate and manage the challenges and demands of their work.
“Always remember that behind every title, there’s a person, and behind every person, there’s also a journey,” said Dr. Tohme. “There’s everything that you have gone through in order to become who you are.”